more Top Stories

Kuribo's Shoe


Advertisements

Player Select

User avatarRank: Koopa Troopa
Joined: Oct 08

Affiliates

  • Destructoid
  • Gamersyde
  • Gamersyde
  • Modojo
  • GameDaily

GN Friends

  • WiiFolder
November 18, 2009 by RawmeatCowboy Filed Under: Wii, Nintendo in general

The results below come from a CNET UK poll that surveyed 1,128 UK-based console owners (of whom 562 owned Xbox 360s, 473 owned PlayStation 3s and 591 had Wiis, with some owning more than one)...

- 60% of 360 owners had experienced hardware failure
- 16% of PS3 owners had experienced hardware failure
- 6% of Wii owners had experienced hardware failure

Also worth noting, Game Informer did a poll of their U.S. subscribers to find out the same information, and 6.8% of Wii owners had experienced hardware failure.

Link


Story Feedback

 
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 17, 2009 at 10:18 pm
There have got to have been at least 5 episodes of the Gonintendo podcast where someone had reported that their 360 failed.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
Hero of legend
November 17, 2009 at 10:32 pm
Tragic, my 5th Wii needs replacing, I've been wondering if it's my Mom's smoking that's been the culprit. :(

And I'm in my own room and she's in our "living room", I guess the smoke does like to creep in. X(
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 17, 2009 at 10:40 pm
Nintendo builds their machine like a tank. And you know what happens to those 6%? They call up Nintendo, and Nintendo sends them a new console along with a pre-paid box to send the old unit back.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 17, 2009 at 10:55 pm
60%!?

Also, hero of legend, I feel your pain, though, I only had to replace one Wii, it happened when I was staying at my in-laws, who smoke.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 17, 2009 at 11:53 pm
There have been times I've left a game paused for up to a week. (Accounting for my 1500+ hours in Zelda.) Gotta love that Nintendo quality.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
Entity
November 18, 2009 at 1:52 am
My Wii still works. BUT it makes a big noise from the disk reader. This has happened with more people and at times the reader fails completely. Hope mine will survive.

@Hero of legend

5th Wii? I do not envy you. But I can not think it is the smoke you mentioned. Maybe the electric cables in your house has some issues., Check it out!
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 3:18 am
@Entity

Yeah the Wii is the most unreliable Nintendo system since the NES in my opinion.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
internet
November 18, 2009 at 3:27 am
unlucky enough to have a gpu failure ( damn resident evil 4 wii!!) but it was nicely handled by nintendo... since it was only ten month old
i know some people had to open their wii to bend some metal part in order to stop the awful noise. check youtube , it's quite hard to do in reality .

so it's no gamecube/supernintendo/n64 , better than the other two but not perfect
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
Entity
November 18, 2009 at 3:32 am
@SEGAsbest

Reall? I only know of 1-2 Wiis that stopped working. Inever had problems with any other system though. NEVER

@internet

Don't really want to open my Wii, but maybe I should. Thanks for the tip though :) Annoying sound I say.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
tootiredtothink
November 18, 2009 at 4:20 am
@Hero of legend

Are you putting the wii on top of a subwoofer or other electronic equipment?

Get a fan for the room to blow the air around it helps to disapiate the smoke.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 4:46 am
Talk about bad luck.. Out of my three current gen consoles my Wii is the only one that has needed repairs.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 5:04 am
@Entity

My Wii tends to make some loud disc reader noises too. Maybe it's just because its only recently that I've noticed it making the noise at all, but honestly I didn't start to notice it until I got the 4.1 update back in the summer. Everything has been playing fine though. My Wii's only locked up 3 times since getting it at launch in 2006, and it happens so infrequently that it's of no concern (my Gamecube did the exact same thing). One time I was playing Spyro: Dawn of the Dragon and the framerate acted up so badly it made me worried I was about to get a disc read error, but then things "fixed themselves" and I realized "oh wait, it's just the game itself" after I put in Overkill next and it ran just fine (sometimes I can confuse a game's framerate flaws with system flaws).
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
toadster101
November 18, 2009 at 5:50 am
My Wii has broken twice. It's the only Nintendo system of mine to ever break.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 5:54 am
My Wii has an overheated GPU, so all of that fuzz stuff appears when a game is using fog, smoke, or light effects. Nintendo should have configured the Wii to keep it's fan on while having WC24 on. That's the only major error I've had with the Wii.

My launch GameCube however, the lens failed after 6 months or so. I then sent it into Nintendo and got a new one that still works to this day. I have never had problems with other consoles, just Nintendo. Compared to the GameCube, N64, and SNES, the Wii feels the cheapest of any Nintendo console.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 5:58 am
ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE IS ANECDOTAL.

*breath*

My launch Wii has worked splendidly since day one so stick that in your pipe and smoke it.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 6:04 am
Ha ha, my wii has remained perfect, my boyfriend's xbox tanked and had to send it back to microsoft for an entire semester. Stat remains true :3
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 6:54 am
@Hongo

For me it was a year and a half with my launch GameCube. It was out of warranty so my mom just bought me a new one in fall 2003. It worked perfectly, even when I sold it last year.

My Xbox 360 on the other hand, while I've never gotten RROD it's had more issues. Game freezing is not an everyday thing, but it happens frequently enough to where I don't panic about it like I do if it were to happen to another system (now I'm like "oh geez it froze... oh well, I'll turn it off for a few minutes and then I'll just turn it back on"). Xbox Live has randomly disconnected for no reason while I was downloading things before, but I've never had to send it in for anything.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 7:06 am
The gpu on my Wii fried like 5 months after launch. My launch 360 had a RROD sometime last summer (lasting nearly 3 years).

So yeah, my situation goes against statistics.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 7:07 am
my system broke 4 months after i got it... but nintendo's customer service was great.. got it back in no time.. just had to redownload all my wiiware/vc games(over 100)... plus i lost all my game saves
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 7:08 am
My Wii got two issues so far, and they were all due to the DVD drive... and one of them could be fixed if I only had a disc cleaner by then :\ (I have one now, one of the best 7 euros I've spent in my life).

Other than that, it works perfectly fine. My only problem with my Wii is the 3rd party batteries for my Wiimotes... but duh. they're 3rd party :P
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 7:14 am
@Tendonin

Call it what you like, it doesn't make it any less true..

I keep all my three consoles in a well ventilated area and an extra fan blowing on them when I play just to be safe and for some reason my Wii first started making a weird noise and then it stopped reading any discs..

I had the lens replaced and it worked fine until recently it started making a similar noise and now it won't read Brawl.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 7:15 am
My Wii has broken. And it's my first system to do so. Just saying.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 7:53 am
Anything with moving parts can fail. The reason why most Nintendo consoles have stood the test of time is because most (excluding the GCN and Wii) have had NO MOVING PARTS. Even then, any electronic device can fail. Nintendo doesn't get the Get Out of Jail card, no one does.

So saying anything BUT Nintendo consoles will fail is both unfair and untrue. The reason the Wii has less of a failure rate is because the tech is a lot older compared to say the 360 or PS3.

I swear, some people on here are so close minded, they don't even get how a large majority of any technology or electronics in general work. Let alone how far it has come.

These same people who hate everything not Nintendo and say it's bad quality yet post on here using Windows XP, Vista, or 7, and talk to their friends on Windows Live Messenger and listen to music on a Zune. People who probably play their Wii on a Sony TV, have a Sony radio in their room and have a Sony brand CD player in their car and probably watch Sony produced movies and shows and listen to music published by Sony Music.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
Entity
November 18, 2009 at 8:00 am
@Eternal Rain


Hmm. I didn't notice the sound until this summer. I am sure it wasn't there before ;)

@BigLord

Great purchase. Have one myself :)
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 8:24 am
All of my friends that have 360 have sent them in for repairs, and alot of my friends have them. Yet, i've had the Wii for almost three years and the only problem i've had was a faulty sensor bar, which Nintnedo was kind enough to send me a brand new one.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 8:25 am
2 years in the running and still work like a charm................ except that it refuses to play metroid prime trilogy while it plays brawl withouth a problem
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 8:36 am
My Wii stopped playing GCN games it takes them makes a loud noice it won't read them and when you press eject they don't even come out. Also I see little scuffs on the disc when they come out of the wii.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
piecolorado
November 18, 2009 at 9:05 am
My Wii died within a week of getting it, with a disk read error. I bought it January after launch. They quickly sent me a replacement, and it has lasted until now. Every once in a while we get a freeze and have to restart it, but it's rare. I've been very happy.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 11:38 am
Only Nintendo system on me to die on me is my supposedly indestructible GameCube, which died three times on me before I decided to replace it with the Wii. And guess what, my Wii hasn't failed once. I guess that goes against what everybody has been saying in this topic.
Send PM Edit Feedback Delete Feedback Report Feedback
User avatar
November 18, 2009 at 7:05 pm
@AlexPuma

Doesn't make our experiences any less factual.
Please log in using your message board account to post feeback.
Don't have an account? Click here to register!