Login

EDGE - Jan. 2018 review scores

Xenoblade Chronicles 2: 7 "It doesn't quite match the out-of-nowhere brilliance of the first game, nor is it as bold as the daring, but flawed, follow-up."

Animal Crossing Pocket Camp: 5 "Somewhere, Animal Crossing has mislaid its soul."

Comments

Animal Crossing Pocket Camp: 5 "Somewhere, Animal Crossing has mislaid its soul."

Sorry, but you're expecting core ideas and game experiences into a mobile market. That RARELY is effective and AC will never be one of them.

Pocket Camp is so disappointing, not unlike all of Nintendo’s mobile output at this point.

Edge has been very anti JRPG for a few years now. 7 is unsurprising for a game I would consider a 9

aurora unit
Sat Dec 02 17 04:49pm
Rating: 1

The first game was brilliant so it got a 9. This one doesn't "quite" match the brilliance of the first... so it gets a 7? That's "quite" a difference...

Not sure about the Xenoblade score, but the Animal Crossing score is spot on (if not even a bit high, perhaps). Animal Crossing on mobile is terrible and that makes me sad.

The news about the Edge scoring this month is the 4 of Battlefront 2

Well, it's as much an Animal Crossing game as Animal Crossing: Stupid Plastic Crap Festival was.

It's a mobile game with AC wallpaper. They've replaced the "no missions, do what you like" attitude with "all missions all the time, go go go go go."

Want to join this discussion?

You should like, totally log in or sign up!